Join Chalkbeat New York’s free every day publication to get important information about NYC’s public colleges delivered to your inbox.
As enrollment in New York Metropolis’s public colleges plunged in recent times, metropolis officers stated reversing the pattern could be a significant precedence.
New statistics provide some clues about why many households left: A want for higher instruction and issues about college security, in accordance with survey outcomes the Schooling Division launched Friday.
About 41% of households who left the system stated extra rigorous instruction was one in every of their high causes for withdrawing. One other 40% cited a transfer away from the town. One in 4 households pointed to issues about college security.
Greater than 1,600 households who transferred their youngsters to native non-public or constitution colleges, home-schooled them, or left the town between September 2022 and December 2023 responded to the survey.
Schooling Division officers framed the survey outcomes as a technique to higher perceive mother and father’ selections, a few of that are tied to broader coverage points equivalent to the town’s dearth of reasonably priced housing. Public college enrollment, which was already on the decline earlier than COVID hit, is now 11% under pre-pandemic ranges, with 815,000 college students in grades Ok-12. And officers predict the numbers will proceed to fall over the following decade.
Metropolis officers have grown more and more frightened about recruiting and retaining households within the nation’s largest college system. Dwindling rosters are prompting troublesome selections about merging and shutting colleges which are usually too small to supply a strong set of packages and extracurricular actions.
Amongst households who departed the town, half listed “issues about colleges” as one in every of their high 5 causes for leaving. Almost two-thirds stated they had been in search of a greater surroundings to lift their household, half stated they had been in search of greater properties, 42% cited issues about crime, and 36% stated they had been in search of extra reasonably priced housing.
Town is attempting to win households again, and officers pointed to some current efforts to enhance the system: overhauling studying and math curriculums and recruiting dad or mum volunteers to assist deal with power absenteeism. Officers are additionally launching a wave of selective excessive colleges in higher-need neighborhoods.
“I’m dedicated to listening to our households and following their lead as we form our colleges to greatest serve our kids,” colleges Chancellor Melissa Aviles-Ramos stated in a press release. “Understanding why households could select to go away a NYC public college is an important a part of that work.”
The survey outcomes are additionally notable for what households didn’t appear to prioritize once they selected packages exterior the town’s public college system.
Solely about one-third of households cited college variety or a culturally related curriculum as important elements. About 41% listed profession preparation packages equivalent to apprenticeships, which public colleges have more and more invested in beneath Mayor Eric Adams. Against this, 74% of households stated they prioritized colleges that felt supportive and welcoming.
Nonetheless, a number of specialists stated the outcomes provided little in the best way of coverage steerage and included important limitations.
Solely about 3% of households who left the town’s public colleges responded to the survey, elevating issues that caregivers who didn’t reply could have been extra prone to provide completely different responses.
Plus, it’s troublesome to interpret what households imply once they listing issues about broad points equivalent to educational rigor or college security, stated Aaron Pallas, a professor at Columbia College’s Lecturers School.
“It’s not one thing that I feel is completely nugatory,” Pallas stated of the survey outcomes. “However, I don’t suppose it’s telling us a lot that’s actionable.” Info the Schooling Division collected from focus teams that had been performed individually from the survey may very well be extra helpful in understanding households’ decision-making at a extra granular degree, he stated.
Jen Jennings, a Princeton College sociology professor who has studied the town’s public colleges, famous there’s usually a disconnect between how folks reply to surveys and the explanations motivating their selections. When households increase issues about college security, as an illustration, some analysis suggests they could be responding to a college’s racial composition, Jennings stated.
Nonetheless, listening to what households say about their enrollment selections may be worthwhile by itself.
“If a worth of the system is getting suggestions and what they’re attempting to do is have interaction households and allow them to know that they care,” Jennings stated, “this might have a very necessary function.”
Alex Zimmerman is a reporter for Chalkbeat New York, protecting NYC public colleges. Contact Alex at azimmerman@chalkbeat.org.
