Martin Scorsese’s lengthy and illustrious profession in movie requires no introduction. However has the legendary director ever dabbled in tv? The reply is sure. From overseeing a couple of episodes of the HBO interval drama “Boardwalk Empire” to helming the Netflix docuseries “Fake It is a Metropolis,” Scorsese has labored within the medium a couple of occasions over time. In 2016, he was even concerned in a somewhat bold tv undertaking: one other HBO interval drama titled “Vinyl,” which he created in collaboration with Mick Jagger, Wealthy Cohen, and Terence Winter. The core concept was to seize the glamor and nostalgia of the report trade within the Seventies, full with raucous spectacle and, possibly, a sprinkle of hedonistic extra.
Commercial
Nonetheless, the issue with “Vinyl” — which begins off sturdy due to its Scorsese-directed pilot — is exactly this determined celebration of extra. With out one thing highly effective or substantial to floor it, “Vinyl” fell into its style trappings of nostalgia bait and commenced to flounder after some extent. Whereas HBO initially deliberate to resume the present for a second season, the choice was later reversed, and the present was finally canceled after its 10-episode first season. To grasp HBO’s reasoning higher, let’s check out what head of programming Casey Bloys needed to say concerning the present’s cancellation in 2016 (per Deadline):
“It did not land. With restricted assets, we did not suppose the retooling was well worth the producers’ time if it could solely transfer the needle a bit bit. We are going to extra rigorously think about issues; it is not one thing that I would love to do or relish doing going ahead.”
Commercial
Whereas that is an comprehensible enterprise determination, Bloys’ assertion paints an incomplete image of “Vinyl,” its ethos, and what it failed to realize regardless of the involvement of gifted creatives. Furthermore, it is price our time to dig deeper and look at the imaginative and prescient that formed the undertaking, in addition to whether or not issues would’ve been totally different if Scorsese was extra concerned with the HBO sequence.
Vinyl was anticipated to realize HBO status drama standing, however it failed
Let me set the scene for the Scorsese-directed, mega-expensive ($30 million!) two-hour opener for “Vinyl.” The yr is 1973, and label proprietor Richie Finestra (Bobby Cannavale) is on the verge of promoting his firm, a choice that comes with a distribution settlement with Led Zeppelin. That is excellent news, however a bizarre encounter with Robert Plant (Zebedee Row) makes it clear that the sale may not occur in any respect. At this level, Richie is clearly harassed and straight-up not having time … till he does a couple of strains of coke and watches the glamorous New York Dolls stylishly belting out their hit single, “Persona Disaster.”
Commercial
Scorsese weaves out and in of private, contained moments and charged communal areas with out effort within the episode, forgoing pathos in favor of specializing in the vulgar extra of dwelling within the second with out a care about penalties. Quiet moments of hysteria or interpersonal battle are stamped out by the spectacle of rock and roll, as Richie is just making an attempt to reside it up and get what he (thinks he) deserves after a string of unhealthy choices. Within the palms of a lesser director, this opener could be a slog, however Scorsese crafts a wealthy tapestry depicting a bygone tradition that does not appear as cool or aspirational as we speak, even with our rose-tinted glasses on.
However “Vinyl” is not making an attempt to satirize this sentiment, as its hedonistic coronary heart is as honest as Richie’s perception that he’s not having an existential disaster. With Scorsese’s involvement as director, these cliched, borderline-boring tropes work, however not a lot in his absence. If something, “Vinyl” loses its means fully by its third episode, regurgitating story beats we’ve got seen one million occasions earlier than.
Commercial
Talking of which, what did Scorsese should say about his short-lived HBO drama? The director expressed his sentiments through the 2018 Rome Movie Competition, lamenting the truth that he did not have a extra hands-on involvement within the present (through The Hollywood Reporter):
“It was finally tragic for me as a result of we tried for one yr. I did the pilot. We tried for one yr with HBO, however we could not get the inventive components collectively. It was one thing that I spotted, with a view to make it proper (…) I believe I might have needed to direct each episode and be there for the three to 4 years.”
There’s extra to Vinyl’s cancellation than meets the attention
Whereas it’s true that Scorsese’s regular involvement might need salvaged “Vinyl” (very similar to it did on “Boardwalk Empire”), we have to discuss concerning the high quality of the present’s post-pilot episodes. Are they actually that unhealthy? To be frank: no. The rankings and viewership numbers weren’t spectacular, however they weren’t abysmal both. Regardless of its mess of regurgitated style tropes, chunk of its viewers loved “Vinyl,” with the essential consensus additionally leaning in the direction of the optimistic. (The present at the moment holds a 74% on Rotten Tomatoes.)
Commercial
So, what have been the explanations behind HBO abruptly cancelling “Vinyl” after having already introduced its renewal? In keeping with Cannavale, HBO dropped the ball whereas planning the present’s launch technique, creating circumstances that the forged and crew had no management over. Because the actor defined to Vainness Honest in 2024:
“You may Monday-morning quarterback this stuff: We actually have been screwed out by circumstances that we did not have any management over. Whether or not it was the truth that HBO did not advertise as a brand new Martin Scorsese film; they did not let their viewers understand it was a two-hour pilot; they did not actually benefit from what that they had; they premiered us after ‘Women’ — did not make any sense. We premiered at 10 at evening for a two-hour pilot.”
Commercial
Cannavale additionally felt personally answerable for the criticism levied in opposition to the sequence, feeling he had “let Marty down” and that HBO’s reversal of the choice to resume “Vinyl” was “like a double f***-you.” Whereas it is comprehensible why Cannavale might need felt that means because the face of this short-lived present, the onus of duty should not fall on one particular person. Furthermore, the enterprise aspect of issues usually outweighs inventive advantage or honest effort, and that is likely to be simply the case with the destiny of this sequence.
“Vinyl” was an costly affair that was alleged to have fun the flawed, glamorous lives of actual musicians and the tradition surrounding the music trade on the time. The present’s failure to fulfill projected expectations mirrored poorly on HBO, because it was unable to churn out a worthwhile status drama even with such prolific names connected. Regardless of the case, Richie Finestra’s desires of a comfortable, prosperous life have been unceremoniously dashed (although I do not suppose too many individuals are up in arms about it).
